Wilfrid · Chapter 53 — Age of Bede

Saint Bede the Venerable; Stephen of Ripon; Anonymous

Open the page reader

Pope John acquits Wilfrid at the Roman synod

One day, the most blessed John, bishop of the Apostolic See, and his most reverend fellow bishops, assembled in holy council, ordered chosen representatives of both the accusers and the defenders to appear before the sacred gathering. This was immediately done. Bishop St Wilfrid and his venerable priests and deacons were brought forward, humble and suppliant. Greeting those honourable faces, they promised from the depths of their hearts to receive and fulfil the decrees of the Apostolic See. The holy archbishop’s envoys also came and stood before them as commanded. They were given an opportunity to speak: they were to choose whichever charge they wished and present it against us first, then proceed in due order to the others in the debate.

They answered: “The first point of our accusation is that this Bishop Wilfrid, now present, stubbornly refused and despised, before the synod, the established judgements of the holy Archbishop Berhtwald of the Church of Canterbury and all Britain, who was sent by this Apostolic See. We have stated our side’s case; now give your defence.”

Then our bishop St Wilfrid, advanced in honourable old age, stood with his venerable brethren before the whole assembly and said: “Humbly and as a suppliant, I beg your most excellent holiness to be pleased to hear from my humble person the truth of what happened. I was sitting in the council with my abbots, priests and deacons. They sent one of the bishops assembled there to ask me, in the name of the king and equally of the archbishop, whether I would consent to the archbishop’s judgement alone, and whether I was wholeheartedly prepared to fulfil whatever he decreed in judgement. I answered his question: ‘What is his sentence? We ought to know before declaring whether we can bear to carry it out or not.’ He asserted that he did not know, and said that the archbishop would not disclose the outcome of his judgement to any of us until, by signing in our own hands before the assembled council, we had declared and confirmed our choice to hold to his judgement alone in everything, without turning aside from it to the right or left. ‘I have never before heard,’ I said, ‘of anyone being compelled into so narrow and binding a constraint that, tied entirely by an oath, he must declare that he will fulfil the decrees imposed, however impossible, before knowing the force of the decision.’ Nevertheless, before that assembly I promised that, in all matters where the archbishop’s judgement accords with the statutes and rules of the holy fathers and the canonical decisions, and is found in no respect whatsoever to differ from the synod of St Agatho and his orthodox successors, we shall be ready to submit with all the strength of our minds.”

Our holy bishop made this defence and then fell silent. The holy synod replied: “Wilfrid, the bishop beloved of God, has set out his defence in accordance with the canons.” They then began a lengthy conversation among themselves in Greek, smiling and keeping their words from us. At last they addressed the accusers: “Dearest brethren, you know the provision of our canons: whenever accusers bring many charges against clerics, if they cannot prove the first one they pursue, they are no longer admitted to the others. Nevertheless, out of honour for the holy archbishop sent by the supreme authority of this Apostolic See, and out of respect for this most blessed Bishop Wilfrid, who is said to have long been wrongfully dispossessed, we shall take pains without weariness to examine every point fully over many days and months. With God and St Peter, prince of the Apostles, revealing and making things clear, we desire to bring the matter to an end.”

After these words our bishop and his brethren, beginning to rejoice in triumph, received leave from the holy synod and returned to their lodgings to prepare for the debates of the coming days. The others, by contrast, went home confounded at the first encounter. As the wind of wisdom dispersed the clouds of lies, and the sun of truth shone through the help of the Lord and St Peter, our worthy holy bishop emerged over the course of many days and months entirely and perfectly cleared of every criminal offence that could justify degradation. To put it briefly, after four months and seventy sittings of the most holy See, he came out purified from the testing furnace, aided in this manner by Apostolic authority. On the third day of holy Easter, the proceedings of the thrice-blessed Agatho’s synod against the perversities of heretics, assembled with 125 orthodox bishops, were read aloud before all the people according to Roman custom. Each bishop had confessed the true faith for his own province and city and confirmed it by his signature. Among other things, this was found in the document: Wilfrid, bishop of the city of York and beloved of God, having appealed to the Apostolic See concerning his cause and having been absolved by its authority in matters both certain and uncertain, was seated in judgement in the synod with 125 other fellow bishops. For the whole northern part of Britain and Ireland, and the islands inhabited by the English and Britons, and also by the Irish and Picts, he confessed the true and Catholic faith and confirmed it by his signature.

On hearing this, all the wise citizens of Rome were astonished. Boniface, Sizentius and several others who had seen and known him in the days of Agatho of blessed memory said that the man now present was indeed Bishop Wilfrid, beloved of God, whom the most blessed Agatho had formerly cleared of his accusers’ charges, absolved by Apostolic authority and sent home. Now once again—alas, what sorrow!—the plots of his persecutors had driven him from his own see. He had discharged the duties of a bishop for forty years and more; yet false accusers, armed with forged documents and reckless boldness—one deacon, as they put it, and all the others without any rank of ecclesiastical dignity—had dared to accuse so distinguished a person, so honourable an old man with his venerable brethren, before the assembly of the Apostolic See. They therefore deserved punishment, wasting away in the deepest confinement of a prison until death. The Roman men affirmed that these speakers had told the truth.

Then the most blessed Pope John of the Apostolic See said: “Let the blessed Bishop Wilfrid, beloved of God, against whom our most careful examination through so many sittings has established no criminal charge, know that he is absolved even of hidden offences by the authority of the blessed Peter, Apostle and prince of the Apostles, who possesses the power of binding and loosing. Our humble insignificance, with the consent of the whole synod, has also decreed that the judgements made concerning him by the blessed Agatho, Benedict the elect and the holy Sergius, bishops of the Apostolic See, be confirmed in written decisions sent to the kings and archbishops by the hand of the blessed Bishop Wilfrid, in the following words.”