Diary

Schizophrenia vs Inner Dialogue and Hearing from God

Timothy · 14 November 2026

When I speak about hearing from God, I am describing what I understand as peaceful communication within my thoughts. I am not describing a voice sounding in the room, or words reaching me through my ears. That distinction matters to how I understand and explain my experience.

I have been diagnosed with schizophrenia. My concern is that clinicians who did not share my faith interpreted my descriptions of hearing from God as reports of audible hallucinations. I felt that the religious language I used was being translated into a clinical meaning that did not accurately reflect what I was trying to describe.

For me, “hearing” in this context is a way of expressing an inward experience of prayer and guidance. I understand that experience through my Christian faith. Someone else may interpret it differently, but I believe any assessment should begin by carefully establishing what I actually experience, rather than assuming what the phrase “hearing God” means.

Tanya Luhrmann’s talk, When God Talks Back, offers a thoughtful introduction to how Christians experience and understand communication with God. I share it to give context to the language of faith and to encourage a more careful conversation about inner experience.

I recognise that an experience being peaceful or internal does not, by itself, settle a medical diagnosis or establish its source. Nor does this video determine whether my diagnosis is correct. My point is that faith deserves to be understood on its own terms, and that my account deserves to be recorded accurately.

I want room for both careful clinical assessment and genuine respect for belief: a conversation in which I can explain my experience, ask questions, and be heard without having to surrender the language through which I understand my faith.

The following video illustrates some auditory and visual experiences that can occur during psychosis. I include it to make clearer what clinicians may mean by hallucinations, alongside my own account of inward experiences that I understand through faith.

This is a dramatisation, not a universal picture of schizophrenia. Experiences vary, and recognising—or not recognising—your experience in a video cannot confirm or exclude a diagnosis.

Content warning: This simulation contains disturbing voices and imagery. The uploader advises against watching it if you have previously experienced psychosis. Viewing is entirely optional.

Christopher C. H. Cook’s Hearing Voices, Demonic and Divine: Scientific and Theological Perspectives examines voice-hearing in Christian scripture and history alongside scientific research. It is relevant to this post because it brings theological and psychological perspectives into the same discussion, providing wider context for careful conversations about faith, inner experience and the language people use to describe what they experience.

Read the book online as a PDF (open-access edition, hosted by the Library of Congress).

For the questions raised in this post, these parts of the book are particularly relevant. Page numbers refer to the printed pages:

These chapters offer context for discussion, not a self-diagnostic test or proof that a particular experience comes from God.

Christian writers also examine these questions in detail. Two Carmelite saints are especially relevant to spiritual discernment:

St John of the Cross. In Ascent of Mount Carmel, Book II, chapters 28–31 (PDF), he distinguishes different kinds of interior words. In chapter 29, he warns that a person’s own reasoning can seem to come from another speaker. In chapter 30, he advises caution and consultation with an experienced confessor or a discreet, learned guide, instead of relying on the experience alone.

St Teresa of Ávila. In The Interior Castle, Sixth Mansions, chapter 3 (PDF), she discusses inward and outward locutions and their discernment. She considers agreement with Scripture, humility and lasting effects, and insists on seeking spiritual counsel before acting (paragraph 18) on important messages or those concerning another person, even when one feels certain.

These are historical accounts of spiritual discernment, not modern clinical criteria for schizophrenia. They help explain Christian language and practice while leaving room for careful, individual medical assessment.

Sign in

Free registration. Use an anonymous display name. No email address or password required—just a passkey.

New here?