Wilfrid · Chapter 29 — Age of Bede

Saint Bede the Venerable; Stephen of Ripon; Anonymous

Open the page reader

How Pope Agatho and the holy synod received our bishop’s documents

When Bishop Wilfrid, beloved of God, reached the aforesaid see safely with all his company, the reason for his coming was reported and became known. At that time Coenwald, a devout monk sent by the holy Bishop Theodore with his letters, had also come to Rome; and the blessed Agatho, pope of the Apostolic See, was aware of the dispute.

More than fifty most holy bishops and priests then assembled in the basilica of our Saviour, the Lord Jesus Christ, called the Constantinian basilica. As they sat together, Agatho, most holy and thrice blessed bishop of the holy, catholic and apostolic Church in the city of Rome, said, “I do not believe your holy brotherhood is unaware of why I have summoned you to this venerable assembly. I wish your reverences to learn and discuss with me the nature of the dissension that has recently arisen in the churches of the island of Britain, where by God’s grace the multitude of the faithful has grown. It has been reported to us both by the accounts of those who have come here from there and by written documents.”

Andrew, the most reverend bishop of Ostia, and John, bishop of Porto, said, “The ordering of all the churches indeed depends upon the judgement of your apostolic authority. You act in the place of the blessed Peter, prince of the Apostles, to whom Christ the Lord, the creator and redeemer of all, gave the keys of binding and loosing. In accordance with the charge laid upon us by your apostolic authority, we sat together some days ago with our fellow bishops and fellow servants and read through each of the documents that envoys from the island of Britain brought to your apostolic pontificate. These included the letters sent on behalf of the most reverend Archbishop Theodore, formerly sent there by the Apostolic See, and the reports of others accompanying those documents against a certain bishop whom they describe as a fugitive and whom they believed had come here. We also read the documents submitted by Wilfrid, beloved of God, bishop of the holy Church of York, who was expelled from his see by the aforesaid most holy archbishop and, appealing to the Apostolic See, came all this way. Although many questions were raised in these documents, we found that he had not been convicted of any crimes according to the precise requirements of the holy canons, and therefore had not been deposed canonically. Nor could his accusers prove by their own statements that he had committed any crimes for which he ought to have been degraded. Rather, we judge that he maintained restraint, since he did not embroil himself in seditious struggles. Before he was driven from his see, he made the circumstances of the affair known to his fellow bishops; and from there the aforesaid Bishop Wilfrid, beloved of God, hastened to this Apostolic See. Here Christ the Lord almighty, who redeemed the holy Church with his blood, established the primacy of the highest priesthood and confirmed the authority of the prince of the Apostles. It belongs, therefore, to the authority of your apostolate to command what arrangements should be made in this matter.”

Agatho, most holy and thrice blessed bishop of the holy catholic Church of the city of Rome, said, “Wilfrid, beloved of God, bishop of the holy Church of York, is reported to be outside the doors of our council chamber. Let him be admitted to our chamber, as he requests, with the petition he is said to have brought.” As Bishop Wilfrid, beloved of God, entered the venerable chamber, he said, “I beg your pontifical blessedness to order that my humble petition be received and read aloud before you.” Agatho, the most holy bishop, said, “Let the petition of Bishop Wilfrid, beloved of God, be received and read aloud before everyone.” John the notary took it and read it to the holy apostolic council.